+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #811236 +++ Created an attachment (id=975730) logcat DEFECT DESCRIPTION: [FM Radio][Audio]FM will not pause while actived sound settings. REPRODUCING PROCEDURES: 1.Insert headset; 2.Launch FM and select one channel to play; 3.Listening FM in background; 4.Settings->sound->adjust Media/Ringer&Notifications/Alarm volume,the sound will play simultaneously with FM;->KO 现象描述： 1.插入耳机 2.进入FM选中一个频道播放 3.后台收听FM 4.设置->声音->调节媒体/铃声/闹钟音量，声音会和FM同时播放->KO 并且调节铃声和闹钟声音会外放。 EXPECTED BEHAVIOUR: KO:FM should pause when adjust Media、Ringer or Alarm volume. ASSOCIATE SPECIFICATION: TEST PLAN REFERENCE: TOOLS AND PLATFORMS USED: USER IMPACT:medium REPRODUCING RATE:5/5 For FT PR, Please list reference mobile's behavior: Soul 3.5 SW12V+FG11 设置中调节声音不会有声音。 TEL: 0752-2611532 ++++++++++ end of initial bug #811236 description ++++++++++ DEFECT DESCRIPTION: REPRODUCING PROCEDURES: EXPECTED BEHAVIOUR: ASSOCIATE SPECIFICATION: TEST PLAN REFERENCE: TOOLS AND PLATFORMS USED: USER IMPACT: REPRODUCING RATE: For FT PR, Please list reference mobile's behavior:

Hi Howie, I think this is current behavior. Do you think this should be feature request in future? Thanks!

I'd ni Hema for Comment 1 since it's Media related.

(In reply to comment #1) > Comment from Mozilla:Hi Howie, > I think this is current behavior. Do you think this should be feature request > in future? > Thanks! Dear Mozilla， This feature already completed in Android ，so our validation engineer report this BUG.

Pin, Please provide your input based on current FMRadio implementation and behavior that we are seeing. I just also came across another bug where volume rocker does not take affect on speaker/headphone volume for FMRadio. Thanks Hema

I think this is an audio channel/policy issue, ask @Randy for further information.

Dear Reporter, I want to clarify the symption: 1.Insert headset; 2.Launch FM and select one channel to play; 3.Listening FM in background; 4.Settings->sound->adjust Media/Ringer&Notifications/Alarm volume,the sound will play simultaneously with FM;->KO ^^^^^^^^^^^ on 4, Has the fm radio ever got paused when user change the volume? I try flame on 2.0 branch, the fmradio could be paused on this case.

(In reply to comment #6) > Comment from Mozilla:Dear Reporter, > I want to clarify the symption: > 1.Insert headset; > 2.Launch FM and select one channel to play; > 3.Listening FM in background; > 4.Settings->sound->adjust Media/Ringer&Notifications/Alarm volume,the sound > will play simultaneously with FM;->KO > ^^^^^^^^^^^ on 4, Has the fm radio ever got paused when user change the volume? > I try flame on 2.0 branch, the fmradio could be paused on this case. Dear Mozilla, on 4,when change the Media volume:the sound will play simultaneously with FM,FM not paused; when change the Ringer&Notifications/Alarm volume:The FM will be paused,but the sound of Ringer&Notifications will be play though speaker PS:I test on 2.0 branch.

NI Wayne to help clarify this issue due to flame can't repo this one..

Triage: Minor issue. Not fixon Woodduck 2.0M.

1. I don't think it's a problem because woodduck could mix FM with multimedia. However flame can't mix by hardware limitation. 2. FM didn't be paused.

per comment 11. This is hardware design. Please feel free to reopen if reporter still have other concern.