Proxy override Host matching inconsistency with Chrome
Categories
(Core :: Networking, enhancement, P3)
Tracking
()
People
(Reporter: eros_uk, Unassigned)
References
(Blocks 1 open bug)
Details
(Whiteboard: [necko-triaged])
Preamble
Proxy bypass/override feature is provided in Firefox (via Network Settings UI and extension proxy.settings API), and in Chrome (via extension chrome.proxy API).
There are a number of inconsistencies between Firefox & Chrome implementation of proxy bypass list.
- Host matching
In Chrome,example.com
only matches the exact host while in Firefox it matches any host containing the string. - PAC
As posed in Inconsistency: Proxy Bypass list, Chrome doesn't apply the bypass list to the PAC which limits its versatility.
Firefox's approach is more beneficial (please keep the feature). - Array vs comma-separated string
Not that important though
📌 The Host matching inconsistency is the subject of this bug filing.
Purpose
Besides the inconsistency with Chrome, the Chrome pattern matching has additional versatility.
Examples:
"foobar.com", "*foobar.com", "*.foobar.com", "*foobar.com:99", "https://x.*.y.com:99".
It enables specific rules to include or exclude subdomains.
Hosts often use subdomain to point to a different server, or different location altogether. For example,api.example.com
may be in a different country comparing to the primary example.com
server.
Location based servers are also common e.g. en.example.com, de.example.com
etc
Furthermore, some subdomains may serve different types of service comparing to the main domain server. The aforementioned situation is more common with proxy servers where often subdomains may point to a proxy-server while the main domain points to a web-server.
Note: In Firefox, the proxy override can match TLD which is quite useful e.g. .fr
(please keep the feature). Chrome documentation does not show TLD matching.
In other words ...
.fr = *.fr
.example.com = *.example.com
Comment 1•2 years ago
|
||
We might want to implement this behind a pref.
Updated•1 year ago
|
Description
•