+++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #666065 +++ +++ This bug was initially created as a clone of Bug #635834 +++ Hi Anurag, I'd like to get another round of mismatched dll reports using the same format as the last round for Firefox 17 and above. Thanks!

:rstrong - here's report for February 2013, Firefox-17 http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.20130201-20130228.firefox17.txt Is this in line with what you are looking for?

The format looks correct though I am surprised that xul.dll doesn't show up more often and when it does it doesn't have version info. Also, other dll's that should have version info such as mozalloc.dll, browsercomps.dll, etc. are missing version info.

I am not sure why certain dll's have the version and certain don't, even couple of xul.dll's have missing version. I will look in this tomorrow by checking the crashid directly with hbase and confirming the raw json. Will keep you posted. -anurag

I ran similar report for fx-18: http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.feb.01.txt column 2 contains the OOID. version number for mozalloc.dll is missing from the original crash dump - see https://crash-stats.mozilla.com/report/index/38bd2ebf-0da0-4724-9876-d024c2130201 We need ted or someone from socorro team to help us answer the missing version number. -anurag

Anurag, if the hash for the dll's can be included I can workaround the missing version info.

I have seen missing dll version info in the past so I wouldn't be surprised if it was normal... I was just surprised at how often it was missing some of the time. For example, in the report you linked to http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.20130201-20130228.firefox17.txt there were only a few that had xul.dll version info xul.dll:1.9.0.3725 xul.dll:1.9.1.3483 xul.dll:1.9.2.3951 xul.dll:1.9.2.3989 xul.dll:1.9.2.3989 xul.dll:1.9.2.3989 xul.dll:1.9.2.3989 xul.dll:1.9.2.3989 xul.dll:1.9.2.4448 xul.dll:1.9.2.4448 The following crash report https://crash-stats.mozilla.com/report/index/38bd2ebf-0da0-4724-9876-d024c2130201 has xul.dll|18.0.1.4764

The crash report: https://crash-stats.mozilla.com/report/index/38bd2ebf-0da0-4724-9876-d024c2130201 belongs to Firefox-18 Reference for the crash report is @ http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.feb.01.txt Given the report is for Firefox-18, DLLs that don't match the report are displayed. Out here, xul.dll has version 18.0.1.4764 which isn't a mismatch and thereby not displayed.

Oh... I want the raw data (my previous reports so matches as well) so I can then count both success and failure.

Basically, the raw data so I can generate the report. If it can be limited to just our dll's that would be handy but I am fine with all dll's.

something like this: 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1357125274 uptime: 6362 secondsSinceLastCrash: -2549053 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssutil3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359262769 uptime: 1516 secondsSinceLastCrash: 151869 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359262951 uptime: 30 secondsSinceLastCrash: 182 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359263834 uptime: 879 secondsSinceLastCrash: 883 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359560005 uptime: 1251 secondsSinceLastCrash: 7516019 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359577382 uptime: 2 secondsSinceLastCrash: 17377 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 freebl3.dll:3.14.0.1 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 nssckbi.dll:1.92.0.0 nssdbm3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 softokn3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708 1 Firefox:18.0 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 buildId: 20121121075611 crashTime: 1359577386 uptime: 1 secondsSinceLastCrash: 4 dllSet: browsercomps.dll:18.0.0.4708 firefox.exe:18.0.0.4708 mozalloc.dll:18.0.0.4708 mozsqlite3.dll:3.7.14.1 nss3.dll:3.14.0.1 smime3.dll:3.14.0.1 ssl3.dll:3.14.0.1 xpcom.dll:18.0.0.4708 xul.dll:18.0.0.4708

Exactly and thanks!

http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.feb.2013.fx17.txt.gz http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.feb.2013.fx18.txt.gz http://people.mozilla.com/~aphadke/mismatch.feb.2013.fx19.txt.gz