Closed Bug 274077 Opened 20 years ago Closed 16 years ago

Adobe acrobat "hangs" when downloading pdf in FF only. Works in IE. (Adobe Acrobat/Reader 7.0.0)

Categories

(Toolkit :: Downloads API, defect)

x86
Windows XP
defect
Not set
critical

Tracking

()

RESOLVED WORKSFORME

People

(Reporter: stephenmcleod, Unassigned)

References

()

Details

(Keywords: hang, regression)

Attachments

(1 file)

User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.7.5) Gecko/20041107 Firefox/1.0 Build Identifier: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.7.5) Gecko/20041107 Firefox/1.0 adobe hangs instead of correctly displaying pdf. only happens in firefox. does not happen in IE. Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. go to www.heroscape.net to the download/scenarios section and attempt to download the "lavascape" pdf file. The direct url is: http://www.heroscape.net/PostNuke/modules.php?op=modload&name=Downloads&file=index 2. Observe that two pages download and then adobe either hangs or errors out. 3. Do the same action in I.E. 6+ and Adobe loads the PDF without error. Actual Results: it downloads the first two pages and then hangs. have observed this on other pdf's on other web pages two. basic problem with adobe through firefox. Expected Results: load all 8 pages and display them.
Keywords: hang
What version of Adobe Acrobat Plugin do you use?
*** Bug 275144 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
This happens for me as well. I am running FF 1.0 final and Adobe Acrobat Reader v6.0 on XP. It seems that FF freezes/blocks when I try to scroll to a page that has not been downloaded yet. In IE the plugin displays the pages as they are downloaded and if I attempt to scroll to a section that has not completed yet blank grey page outlines are displayed.
Can you try using reader v7?
Same problem for me - using Adrobe reader 7.0 on Win XP and Win 2000 It just doesn't open the pdf file.
I have the same problem: when I try to download a pdf file from a website, Firefox opens a new window, it stays blank, and that's it (no download). IE downloads perfectly. I am using the firefox I downloaded on Jan 19, 2005, and Adobe Professional 6.0. Thx. Brenda
More information: Here's the software that the author used to create the pdf file document that doesn't open in Firefox. As it only crashes on some sorts of pdf files and not others, this may be a key item: "it's Ghostscript 8.11 and GSview 4.5" Thanks, Edmund R. Kennedy, PE
Oops, forgot to explicitly mention that I'm using Adobe 7.0 not 6.*
Would be useful to explore the possibility of incorporating the Opera browser model for opening Adobe Acrobat/PDF files? While IE and Firefox have both consistently given trouble re: PDF files, Opera is remarkably smooth. just a suggestion
The main cause of PDF problems in Firefox are that the PDF association in FireFox gets doubled up on if you have a previous version of the Acrobat reader in FF and then upgrade to a newer one - both associations are left in FF and FF gets confused as to which version of the reader to use so it locks up. The simple solution is to remove the association in FF with the old PDF reader and then install the new version.
*** Bug 274123 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
This problem can be circumvented by changing the download manager's history setting to remove files from the download manager "upon successful download", from the default setting "manually". I tested this circumvention with Firefox 1.0.4 in SuSE Linux, WinXP and 2k (both at SP2). More complete instructions to verify the problem, fix, and verify the circumvention are at http://cwclark.com/FIREFOX_Hangs.html
(In reply to comment #10 How do you do that, exactly? > The main cause of PDF problems in Firefox are that the PDF association in > FireFox gets doubled up on if you have a previous version of the Acrobat reader > in FF and then upgrade to a newer one - both associations are left in FF and FF > gets confused as to which version of the reader to use so it locks up. The > simple solution is to remove the association in FF with the old PDF reader and > then install the new version.
It happens to me in FF 1.05 aswell. It did it at this URL: http://www.maschinenbau.tu-ilmenau.de/mb/wwwtm/common/Resagk_Grabow_2000.pdf Works fine in IE.
confirmed against ff 1.0.6 deerpark shows similar behaviour: when opening a pdf it just shows either a black or grey page and kills the right mouse button and all the hotkeys. it seems to happen randomly, because some pdf's are working fine. adobe acrobat reader plugin version 7.00
This is a regression. Without changing Acrobat, switching from a pre 20050816 build to a 20050820+ build shows this problem. Not sure of the exact build dates, but the regression window is somewhere close to those dates.
Keywords: regression
This is pretty serious. It has stopped all use of Firefox here in the office as PDFs are unuseable. Not only does FF freeze, but all the toolbar icons disappear and the system is generally hung at that point.
This URL no longer works
Problem when 6.0 is probably DUP of Bug 214137 (already WORKSFORME since resolved by 6.0.1). (In reply to comment #5) > Same problem for me - using Adrobe reader 7.0 on Win XP and Win 2000 It just > doesn't open the pdf file. (In reply to comment #8) > Oops, forgot to explicitly mention that I'm using Adobe 7.0 not 6.* (In reply to comment #15) > adobe acrobat reader plugin version 7.00 To bugs@gbrt2004.co.uk, Edmund R. Kennedy, and DZ : Problem when Adobe Reader 7.0(or later) is probably diffrent issue, since problem when Adobe Reader 6.0(.0) was resolved by Adobe Acrobat 6.0.1. Problem when Adobe Reader 7.x is better to be handled in separate bug. See dependency tree of Bug 336184 (Meta bug for hang/freeze/crash with Adobe Reader plugin), and comment to appropriate bug if you are still experencing hang/freeze/crash with newest Adobe Reader 7.x.
Summary: Adobe acrobat "hangs" when downloading pdf in FF only. Works in IE. → Adobe acrobat "hangs" when downloading pdf in FF only. Works in IE. (Adobe Acrobat 6.0)
If the issue with Acrobat 6 is bug 214137, and the issue with Acrobat 7.0 is not this bug, what is this bug?
(In reply to comment #20) I couldn't find older bug than Bug 290682(opened on 2005-04-17) for hang/crash when Adobe Acrobat/Reader 7.0.x (see dependency tree of Bug 336184). So Comment #5(on 2005-01-15) looks for me to be the first problem report on Adobe Acrobat/Reader 7.0.0. Jerry Baker, do you think this bug is better to be kept open as bug report for problem when Adobe Acrobat/Reader 7.0.0(and later)?
Oh, sorry, your Comment #16 was in this bug. I knew about your finding of Comment #16 by comment in a bug report of Bugzilla Japan, but I missed it was comment in this bug. Jerry Baker, is your Comment #16 for Adobe Reader 7.0.0 or later? or for Adobe Acrobat (Reader) 6.0.x? Or for both? Is this bug for regression of Firefox(your comment Comment #16) which is common for Firefox with Adobe Acrobat Reader 6.x and Firefox with Adobe Reader 7.x? Should we test combination of Firefox pre 20050816 build and Adobe Reader 7.0.5/7.0.7?
Acrobat 7.
(In reply to comment #23) > Acrobat 7. Since (1) No response from bug opener about PDF plugin version, (2) Many valuable comments on 7.0.0, (3) Commnet #5 looks to be first report about 7.0, (4) Finding about regression of Firefox by comment #16, I believe this bug is to be kept as (first) bug for 7.0 related problem. Changing summary(6.0 => 7.0.0). To all comment posters on 6.0(.0): Problem when Adobe Acrobat (Reader) 6.0.0 is DUP of Bug 214137. See Bug 214137, please.
Summary: Adobe acrobat "hangs" when downloading pdf in FF only. Works in IE. (Adobe Acrobat 6.0) → Adobe acrobat "hangs" when downloading pdf in FF only. Works in IE. (Adobe Acrobat/Reader 7.0.0)
(In reply to comment #16) > switching from a pre 20050816 build to a 20050820+ build shows this problem. Bug 339166 has reported regression during 200508 when Acrobat Reader 5.0.0 on Win 95. > works 2005080905 > broken 2005081005
seems to be resolved by copying nppdf32.dll from \acrobat\plugins folder to \firefox\plugins folder
(In addition to comment #25) Bug 339166 was closed as DUP of Bug 309935 on 2006-05-25, and Bug 309935 was closed as FIXED on 2005-12-17. > Bug 339166 : acrobat 5 pdf plugin doesn't work anymore > Bug 309935 : SeaMonkey ignores Acrobat plug-in directives, > brings up handling dialog box instead
QA Contact: ali → download.manager
I solved this problem:- I use adobe Acrobat Professional and had blank pages only come up when clicking on PDF downloads. Solution:- go to this URL and download addon plugin https://addons.mozilla.org/addon.php?id=636 plus open Adobe and EDIT/Preferences/Internet - uncheck "display PDF in Browser" Worked for me!! This should also work for anyone who only has the READER installed. Drrn Serious
Assignee: bugs → nobody
Does anyone else think three years is a long time to fix this bug? I'm going back to IE because this problem is a real hassle. I've been a happy firefox user for several years, but this is adobe reader hanging is no fun :(
I agree. Same problem with FF 2.0.0.3. lockup whole browser with busy cursor. http://dor.wa.gov/Docs/Forms/ExcsTx/ExmptFrm/ResaleCertificate_E.pdf
http://www.praxis-his.com/pdfs/Logic_versus_magic.pdf Hi guys, this PDF document was not loading - no problem except that I could not quit out of this tab. I tried escape, the stop button everything. It was constantly busy! Then I realized something else.... There was an Adobe error dialog that says there was an error loading the document, but I could not get focus to it! Not alt-tab for refocusing, not by clicking it! NOTE: Mouse cursor was a constant hour glass, in firefox. Windows make window button did not work (between minimize and close). Windows Close button [x] gives the typical application not responding error! When I closed it off I got the typical report to Microsoft error. Version Information: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.8.1.3) Gecko/20070309 Firefox/2.0.0.3
http://www.praxis-his.com/pdfs/Logic_versus_magic.pdf Hi guys, this PDF document was not loading - no problem except that I could not quit out of this tab. I tried escape, the stop button everything. It was constantly busy! Then I realized something else.... There was an Adobe error dialog that says there was an error loading the document, but I could not get focus to it! Not alt-tab for refocusing, not by clicking it! NOTE: Mouse cursor was a constant hour glass, in firefox. Windows make window button did not work (between minimize and close). Windows Close button [x] gives the typical application not responding error! When I closed it off I got the typical report to Microsoft error. Also I got the adobe viewer to show a taskbar entry and I could focus on the dialog and click ok. Version Information: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.8.1.3) Gecko/20070309 Firefox/2.0.0.3
Attached image MS Dialog where the error occured (deleted) —
Close Task error dialogs
To bug opener and all problem reporters: Same question as Bug 351762. Does your crash or hang or freeze occur even after Adobe Reader 8.1?
I've tested with FF 2.0.4/Adobe Reader 8.1 on Windows XP Pro SP2 and the problem seems to be gone. I upgraded from Adobe Reader 7.0 where I had the problem.
Under FF 2.0.0.8 Adobe reader 8.1 on Windows XP SP2, the problem sill remain. Downloading a pdf file pointed in a page make the browser bugging. Ex. www.vertex.fr
Same here I use acrobat 7 when i try to download a file it just opens a new tab or window and nothing happens.
adobe 8.1.2 locks my firefox 3.0b3 release, and I cant turn adobe off via plugins. Thats Bug 229196
(In reply to comment #36) > Under FF 2.0.0.8 Adobe reader 8.1 on Windows XP SP2, the problem sill remain. > Downloading a pdf file pointed in a page make the browser bugging. > Ex. www.vertex.fr To BABINET: As seen in dependency tree for meta bug 336184, crash/freeze with Adobe Reader 8.x is very few (I know problem of Bug 383826 and following crash of Bug 368821 only). This bug is for crash/freeze in 7.0.x era. If crash/freeze when Adobe Reader 8.x can be observed frequently with specifc site, open separate bug with setting 336184 in "Blocks:", please.
I've got Adobe Reader 8.1.2 on Firefox 3.0. FF hangs when I try to scroll down the document before it finishes loading. No error dialogs show up even when I force quit. When I reload the page and wait for the file to cache I don't get any hangs. If I exit FF, restart and reload the page I can scroll with no hangs. So, once the pdf file is cached there's no problem. I'll try comment #28's solution and report back.
Well, comment #28's link is broken. Unchecking "Display PDF in Browser" of course stopped displaying pdf's in the browser. Rechecking it allowed pdf's. That's about it. The problem still exists. For anyone else reporting a pdf problem. As in #40, if the full pdf file loads and gets cached it will no longer show the problem. Make sure you clear the cache before retrying the file. You may think the problem is solved when it isn't. Firefox 3.0 Adobe Reader 8.1.2 plugin: nppdf32.dll pdf: http://ideas.aetn.org/__data/assets/pdf_file/0018/3834/Teachscape_HY_catalog.pdf
(In reply to comment #40 & comment #41) To raymond shpeley: As you say, PDF related hang/freeze/crash still remains even after Adobe Reader 8, but it seems to be limited to special situations such as your "scroll down the document before it finishes loading". I could find only following three reports of "PDF related hang/freeze/crash" after Adboe Reader 8. 1. Bug 383826(PDF download error) then Bug 368821(Crash), when test case of Bug 368821(many IFRAMEs with PDF). 2. Yours : Hang when "scroll down the document before it finishes loading". 3. Bug 429242 : Hang when quick cancel after PDF link click. See dependency tree for Bug 336184. Closing as WORKSFORME, based on many answers to my question of comment #34. (no need to track Adobe Acrobat Reader 6 & Adobe Reader 7 problems any more)
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 16 years ago
Resolution: --- → WORKSFORME
Product: Firefox → Toolkit
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Created:
Updated:
Size: